South Carolina High School Student Dragged From Class

[Ike Bana]

Originally Posted by BeamOn

I am willing to bet one $ that she will be expelled and needs to be expelled. Her refusal to obey her teachers cannot be condoned as this will be read as a free pass by the rest of the student body and would be a slap in the face to LE, in spite of this one officer's actions. Both parties in this instance were wrong.

Partially agreed. Perhaps completely agreed if you can specify which parties are included. I can't agree that the school administration did anything wrong...including calling the resource officer in.

[Dondilion]

Originally Posted by Ike Bana

Partially agreed. Perhaps completely agreed if you can specify which parties are included. I can't agree that the school administration did anything wrong...including calling the resource officer in.

She defied three levels of authority...regular teacher, vice principal and police.

However I would have preferred that a female officer be involved.

[Boreas]

Originally Posted by Dondilion

However I would have preferred that a female officer be involved.

I don't know why this would have made a difference. The problem was the level of the police response, not the gender of the responder.

And, if there had been any action taken by the police that might have compromised the girl's privacy, then a female officer would have been appropriate..... but the whole thing went down in the classroom so the gender of the officer ended up not mattering in the slightest.

[Dondilion]

Originally Posted by Boreas

I don't know why this would have made a difference. The problem was the level of the police response, not the gender of the responder.

And, if there had been any action taken by the police that might have compromised the girl's privacy, then a female officer would have been appropriate..... but the whole thing went down in the classroom so the gender of the officer ended up not mattering in the slightest.

The authority expected to remove her physically. (She just wasn't yielding.) I would prefer that be accomplished by females.

[JJIII]

Kinda like mud wrestling?

[donquixote99]

Originally Posted by Boreas

Jesus, are you for real?

Complete and utter bullshit! Look at the fucking video again or, better yet, grab the first stranger you see walking by your house and ask them what they see.

The deputy grabbed her in a choke hold with his right arm, grabbed under her left thigh with his left hand and then tipped her and her desk over backward. Her feet weren't even touching the floor! She couldn't have tipped herself over if she'd wanted to.

I'm telling you, Ike, the contortions you're going through trying to blame this girl for the cop's actions are obscene. Combine that with your absurd efforts to accuse everyone else in the debate of race baiting and it begs the question of what your true agenda is.

His agenda is for us to beat him up. Go figure.

[68custom]

while I agree that she should be expelled for her lack of respect for authority, though not thrown to the ground and dragged out of the room. I suspect that by now the lawyers are involved and a payday may be forthcoming for the errant student.

[MrPots]

Originally Posted by Dondilion

She defied three levels of authority...regular teacher, vice principal and police.

However I would have preferred that a female officer be involved.

Yes, and in this country we must all drop whatever we are doing and immediately obey the fucking "Authorities" no matter who they are or what their motivation (anyone with any level of government job apparently).

Obey without question, right to wrong, or be punished. And that "authority gets to dictate the punishment even if it means death....screw the courts.

Thats fucking the freedom they tell us our troops are fighting for.

This is why I cannot respect "the troops". Not only do they suck up untold billions in tax dollars, they are failing so miserably at protecting our freedoms.

[Ike Bana]

Originally Posted by Boreas

I don't know why this would have made a difference. The problem was the level of the police response, not the gender of the responder.

And, if there had been any action taken by the police that might have compromised the girl's privacy, then a female officer would have been appropriate..... but the whole thing went down in the classroom so the gender of the officer ended up not mattering in the slightest.

You might consider if it mattered to the girl...uncomfortably out of character as such consideration would be for you.

[Rajoo]

Originally Posted by MrPots

Yes, and in this country we must all drop whatever we are doing and immediately obey the fucking "Authorities" no matter who they are or what their motivation (anyone with any level of government job apparently).

Obey without question, right to wrong, or be punished. And that "authority gets to dictate the punishment even if it means death....screw the courts.

Thats fucking the freedom they tell us our troops are fighting for.

This is why I cannot respect "the troops". Not only do they suck up untold billions in tax dollars, they are failing so miserably at protecting our freedoms.

Out of context wouldn't you think? On one hand we are dealing with teenage high schoolers and their lack of respect for authority vs. adults under the thumbs of perceived governmental authority.