Quote:
Originally Posted by Independent
Doesn't everyone in this country, outside of inheritence (I don't count this because I certainly won't inherit anything), start out with the same opportunities as anybody else? So, because I work harder, or the right opportunities fall my way, or I win the lottery, I'm supposed to share what I have, over-and-above a proportionate tax, to someone who might not be as motivated, or as lucky as I am? That should be my choice to do, not mandated.
|
unfortunately, we are NOT all created equals. the income level of your parents plays a
tremendous role in your ability to get ahead financially. genetics plays a very important role also. some people are just not smart enough to become doctors or lawyers, no matter how hard they work. and "the right opportunities falling your way" is pure luck. some have it, some don't.
what you are implying is that a person born to poor parents, in a poor neighborhood, who attends a low-performing school, is of average or below intelligence and appearance (also plays a tremendous role in success), and is not very fortunate otherwise, should have to pay more (or at least the same)in taxes that you do.
winning the lottery or any other such windfalls is an exception to the rule, not the rule.