donquixote99 |
09-25-2015 06:02 AM |
Comments on 'Why Permaculture leads to anarchy'
It leads to real solutions, often that are illegal but work Solutions that work are good, but getting busted can cancel that. Resist the temptation to make 'illegal' a desired thing in itself. Ethics based and concerned with “people care” Good. But this is a cultural feature NOT implied by the agricultural science of permaculture (a fact true of most of this list, I'd say.) Teaches the practice of currency creation and private banking See 'illegal,' above. Culture, not permaculture. It is a design science which causes you to question everything Good. No room for bureaucracy, a tree doesn’t’ care about your title The trees won't be the one's doing it. There will always be cops and courts and an army (nothing is more bureaucratic than an army). There will be guys working full-time as interdependence coordinators. There will be guys in charge of it all, and guys who work for them. There will be taxes to pay for it all. Even hunter-gatherers have bits of this. All agricultural societies have plenty of it. A meritocracy in other words those that get shit done succeed Hah! the chiselers are always with us. It is about rewilding humans to live with nature vs. opposing it. 'Nature' is just an idea created by humans. Stick to 'what works,' and 'design science' and 'getting things done.' Myths about nature will just get in the way, and empower bureaucrats and chiselers. Promotes community interdependence vs system and centralized dependence Good. Whatever works. But community interdependence is a system. Focuses on real wealth above persevered wealth You mean Buckminster Fuller's definition of wealth, measured by counting days into the future you can live on what you've got? Isn't one kind of that as real as another? Creates wealth that is hard if not impossible to tax Ha ha ha. If you ever have enough wealth to draw attention, you'll see. Leads naturally to commerce at a local level Which leads naturally to more bigger and less local commerce, when it works. Can not be controlled, policed, slowed down or stopped by the oligarchy Ha ha ha. Avoid drawing attention as much as you can. Test this notion and you'll be sorry. Final thoughts on what real freedom is and why morality is required for it Read your Dostoyevsky.
|